World Bank slammed for urging shift in local agriculture
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
The environmental nongovernment organization Interface Development Inteventions, Inc. (Idis) has slammed a World Bank recommendation for the Philippines to devote its budget for agriculture on export-oriented crops.
Lia Jasmin Esquillo, executive director of Idis, said that World Bank wanted the millions of farmers in the country to get stuck to the pit of hunger and poverty with this kind of recommendation.
“The idea that Filipino farmers must plant exportable crops has always been proven as destructive to the economic backbone of the country which is agriculture and threatens the capacity of the farmers to conduct their activities sustainably—meaning really beneficial to them and friendly to the environment,” Esquillo said.
“Let us be reminded that only the capitalists and their cohorts were able to benefit when rice, corn, coconut and other indigenous crop farmers shifted to planting pineapples, Cavendish bananas, and crops that are export oriented…Let us not be deceived by these sugar coated analysis because we have the best weapon to counter them and that’s experience,” Esquillo added.
This came when Maryse Gautier, country director of World Bank for the Philippines, said that the rest of the developing world, the farming sector of the Philippines, which accounts to 40 percent of the country’s workforce, must be placed at the center of the development agenda.
Gautier said that the way to increase the benefits of agricultural public investments in the Philippines “would be to improve the composition of expenditure, without necessarily increasing its level.
"The country would be able to seize new opportunities presented by the global markets by shifting expenditures towards supporting dynamic, high-value added products with export potential.
This, she said, will help increase incomes from agriculture, where “more than 40
percent of the Philippine labor force is employed, but which (now)
contributes only about 14 percent of national output."
But Esquillo said that instead of focusing on crops with export potentials, the Philippine government must first and foremost ensure food self sufficiency and give its full support and assistant to farmers who continue to plant corn, rice and other crops that assure the country’s food security. She added that even the United Nations have recognized the potential of organic agriculture to remedy the global problem of hunger, hence the support must be poured on local organic agriculture movements.
“It is appalling to hear someone encourage Filipinos to supply food to other countries when many Filipinos are suffering from hunger and poverty because of lack of food. While we recognize the potential of the country to host agricultural farms, these farms must foremost serve the interest of the Filipino people and not other any other country’s interest,” Esquillo said.
Esquillo said that right now, thousands of lands in the countryside have been given up to plantations that generally threaten the supply of food for local consumption.
She said that farmers who have been swayed into converting their farms into plantations have already been experiencing the ugliness of the trade with their debts piling up, making recovery almost impossible to reach.
“We have already seen how producing food for other countries like the United States and Japan have made our local farmers suffer almost irrevocable damages…let us put an end to this kind of scheme that only impairs the Filipinos capacity to agricultural self-reliance,” Esquillo said.
Lia Jasmin Esquillo, executive director of Idis, said that World Bank wanted the millions of farmers in the country to get stuck to the pit of hunger and poverty with this kind of recommendation.
“The idea that Filipino farmers must plant exportable crops has always been proven as destructive to the economic backbone of the country which is agriculture and threatens the capacity of the farmers to conduct their activities sustainably—meaning really beneficial to them and friendly to the environment,” Esquillo said.
“Let us be reminded that only the capitalists and their cohorts were able to benefit when rice, corn, coconut and other indigenous crop farmers shifted to planting pineapples, Cavendish bananas, and crops that are export oriented…Let us not be deceived by these sugar coated analysis because we have the best weapon to counter them and that’s experience,” Esquillo added.
This came when Maryse Gautier, country director of World Bank for the Philippines, said that the rest of the developing world, the farming sector of the Philippines, which accounts to 40 percent of the country’s workforce, must be placed at the center of the development agenda.
Gautier said that the way to increase the benefits of agricultural public investments in the Philippines “would be to improve the composition of expenditure, without necessarily increasing its level.
"The country would be able to seize new opportunities presented by the global markets by shifting expenditures towards supporting dynamic, high-value added products with export potential.
This, she said, will help increase incomes from agriculture, where “more than 40
percent of the Philippine labor force is employed, but which (now)
contributes only about 14 percent of national output."
But Esquillo said that instead of focusing on crops with export potentials, the Philippine government must first and foremost ensure food self sufficiency and give its full support and assistant to farmers who continue to plant corn, rice and other crops that assure the country’s food security. She added that even the United Nations have recognized the potential of organic agriculture to remedy the global problem of hunger, hence the support must be poured on local organic agriculture movements.
“It is appalling to hear someone encourage Filipinos to supply food to other countries when many Filipinos are suffering from hunger and poverty because of lack of food. While we recognize the potential of the country to host agricultural farms, these farms must foremost serve the interest of the Filipino people and not other any other country’s interest,” Esquillo said.
Esquillo said that right now, thousands of lands in the countryside have been given up to plantations that generally threaten the supply of food for local consumption.
She said that farmers who have been swayed into converting their farms into plantations have already been experiencing the ugliness of the trade with their debts piling up, making recovery almost impossible to reach.
“We have already seen how producing food for other countries like the United States and Japan have made our local farmers suffer almost irrevocable damages…let us put an end to this kind of scheme that only impairs the Filipinos capacity to agricultural self-reliance,” Esquillo said.